One of the more popular things people have been doing recently in the board game community is culling board games from their collection. I even do a rare “Point of Sale” series of articles, you can see them here. But that isn’t what this article is about, well, not completely anyways. But let’s start with culling and then move into other ways you can downsize your collection.

Culling Games

This is sort of a Marie Kondo thing that has been everywhere. The idea is to downsize the things that don’t give you joy. Though, people often take it too far. They clear out a ton of things in their lives and then realize that they wanted some of that or have to get some of it again. This is very true in board games as well.

There most definitely is something freeing about getting rid of stuff. Having too much stuff can feel oppressive and overwhelming. And people often get on a roll of culling games or things from their life. With board games people often use the standard of, have I played this recently, which isn’t a great standard. But they do other things as well, do I like other games better that do the same thing is one of them.

Let’s talk about these two standards for culling.

Have I Played This Game Recently

I don’t like this standard, some of it is because I probably have enough games and expansions to play one game a year without repeats or close to that. But even without that, let’s look back at the past 14 months. How many party games have gotten played, how many social deduction games have gotten played? The answer is, probably not that many for a lot of people. So while people have had time around their house to go through and cull collections, if it is based off of play, there are certain games that just won’t be played.

Taking this logic as well, some games, Heroes of Land, Air, and Sea for example, will get played less often for me. It is a big long game. If it gets played once every two years, that’s often enough for that game, I think. For some people they’d play it more, but for me that isn’t going to be the case. Still, it’ll stay in my collection as a 4X fantasy game.

But let’s go onto a way I like better for culling games.

Do I Have Other Games I like Better, That Do The Same Thing

What does this one mean? Let me give you an example. Splendor is a very simple tableau and engine building game. I think it’s okay, I wouldn’t pull it off the shelf. If I want that engine building experience, I have Space Base, Century: Golem Edition, and Homebrewers that I like better as engine builders. So I will pull them off the shelf first. Now, in all fairness, I haven’t gotten rid of Splendor, but this is an example of one that I could cull. If it wasn’t one that my wife liked a lot and can teach herself, I’d probably get rid of it.

The concept is basically, would I reach for this game on my shelf over other games of the same type? Ask me if I’d reach for a game like Claim over Gloomhaven, no, I wouldn’t. At least most of the time I wouldn’t. But they are two massively different types of games. So compare within a type. Gloomhaven versus Sword & Sorcery is a good example. I wouldn’t pick to play Sword & Sorcery again over playing Gloomhaven again. So I ended up selling Sword & Sorcery.

How Do You Downsize Without Culling?

There’s one main way that you can downsize stuff. And that’s condensing boxes which can be done in a couple of ways. With small games it’s about removing them from the oversized boxes, or moving expansions and everything into fewer boxes. Let’s dive into each of them.

To A Smaller Box

This is one that I actually haven’t done yet, but I could do with a number of games. I know of it more from The Dice Tower where they have a lot of small games in photo boxes, basically hard plastic shells, and then those in larger photo storage boxes, so you can get a lot of small games in.

Going to small boxes works because of how sales and shelf space work. A small game is going to get overlooked more often on a shelf of a store. People will glance over it and buy the bigger game that costs more. So companies smartly so, put stuff into boxes that take up more space and catch more attention.

However, at home, I don’t have all the shelf space in the world. So a game in a bigger box than need be, that eats into how many games I can reasonably fit. Now, that might be a sign to cull some games, but fairly often smaller games getting culled barely helps this situation. Instead, you can store more small games compactly by putting them into photo cases or something like that to free up room.

All To One Box

This is the one that I tend to do, which is look to see how many boxes I can get rid of for my board games. Often times inserts that are well done, or poorly done, will eat up room within a box, and then you get an expansion for a game. The biggest one I can call out for this is Marvel United. They had great inserts, but that means that there were 8 total boxes. By removing inserts and moving stuff around, I easily fit it into 3 boxes. I went from 8 game boxes to 3 boxes. That’s a huge difference when it comes to shelf space.

I am going through my collection to see what I can do that with. I’ve found some other games, all the small expansions for Aeon’s End can fit into their respective big boxes, so that frees up room. But beyond that, eventually I’ll be able to put Aeon’s End into even fewer bigger boxes. Ascension went from 3 boxes down to one by adjusting the an insert, and I can probably even make it fit better by completely removing the insert and creating one of my own for the game.

This is a really easy way for a lot of games to free up a chunk of room. It kind of goes that shelf space thing again. Some games will take up more space if you keep your expansion box. Just condensing down a handful of games frees up a lot of space. With that said, it also means you need to know how and where the expansion stuff is to split it out, which sometimes is easier said than done. So that is a downside, but some games like Marvel United or Sentinels of the Multiverse or even Marvel Champions it doesn’t matter much.

How Do You Downsize Space Without Culling Games?

Are there any other ways that you can free up space, without getting rid of games? A lot of gamer habits, putting sleeves on cards and upgrading games with fancier bits can cause it to take more room. But are there other ways to make games take up less room that you’ve found? I guess trimming boxes shorter so that it more accurately fits what is in side would be a way as well, but I haven’t heard of people doing that. Let me know your ideas in the comments below.

Email us at nerdologists@gmail.com
Message me directly on Twitter at @TheScando
Visit us on Facebook here.
Support us on Patreon here.