It’s coming up on that time of the year again. The school year is upon us, granted that doesn’t change much for me, but that change of the season is what tells me it’s time to start putting together my Top 100 board games of all time again. Yes, it is, as always of all time. So let’s talk through the process and how you can make one for yourself.

When Should You Rank Your Top 100 Board Games?

This is the first question I want to get out of the way. I know it crops up when other places do their Top 100 Board Games Of All Time, like Man vs Meeple and The Dice Tower. It’s the question, when do I have enough games played to make a good Top 100 Board Games list? The answer is, when you have 100. Unless one of them is horrible. Just kidding. I want to know the board games that you don’t like and I want to know the ones that you do.

Just because something is ranked at 100 doesn’t mean it’s good. It’s kind of the opposite problem that Tom Vasel from the Dice Tower has. He plays so many games that his 100 is a game that he truly loves and he could probably go out to 2000 and it’d still be games that he likes. So just remember that 100 games is enough to do you Top 100 Board Games list.

And one last thing when you make your list. A list is just a moment in time. So you might look back at it and go, how did I like that game? You did in that moment. So don’t stress about it too much and also why 100 games is totally the right number.

The Tools

Board Game Geek

Firstly, let’s start off with Board Game Geek or BGG. If you are not familiar with this site, BGG is like IMDb for board games. It allows you to rate games, it allows you to track plays, and keep track of your collection. The big thing for BGG in the process of creating a Top 100 Board Games is rating your games. If you don’t, it’s hard to know and remember which one’s you’ve played. So create a free account, and we’ll go over in the next section why it matters.

Pub Meeple

So, then you need to rank your games. Now you might think that rating them is all you need to do. But there is a twist on that of course, when you do a Top 100 Board Games list, what differentiates one nine from another nine? That is where you need to get everything figured out and where Pub Meeple comes in.

The Set-Up

Pub Meeple has a ranking engine where you can enter lists of whatever you want. But more importantly, it has a board game ranking section. And that section allows you to enter in your BGG user name and it’ll collect all of your games for you. It might take a bit to do that if you have a massive collection of games, and the BGG system is not the fastest system to get data from.

Once you do that you need to filter it. There are a few ways that you can filter it. The big thing is to deselect “Own” and “Played” because if you are like me, you didn’t start tracking your plays from your dawn of gaming, and select rated games. Now, if you want, you can then use another feature as well. You can use the slider for personal ratings until you drop off a number of them. For example, I might drop off 5 and below. Because I know they won’t make the list.

Once everything is added, you click the rank button and that’ll tell you how many different comparisons it might take to do. Let’s go on and talk about how you rank.

The Ranking

So now we’re to the biggest part of ranking. The actual ranking of the board games, and I want to talk about how Pub Meeple makes it work and why it’s great but also why it might show you a ton of different comparisons.

Pub Meeple works on a binary comparison system. By that I mean it takes two things and says is A better than B. And then it is going to ask you if C is better than D and so on. And now, that seems like a lot of comparisons, and for me, with 652 games ranked (and I need to verify that I haven’t missed any), that is 3381 comparisons.

If you are strong at math, I only know it because I can ballpark it, you know that number isn’t the total number of comparisons if you compare A to B and then A to C and so on. That’s because of how this sort of sorting can work.

Example

Let’s look at an example. You rank Game A over Game B and then you rank Game D or Game C. Now it is going to give you the comparison of Game A and Game D. If you say that Game D is better than Game A it is now going to ask you the question if Game A is better than Game C. Let’s say that you say that it is, then your ranking will be Game D, Game C, Game A, and Game B.

Now, you might be thinking, why isn’t Game B compared against any of the other games? Game A gets compared to D and C but not Game B. That’s because Pub Meeple is saying something is true, or more so, you are telling it something is true. You are telling it that Game B is worse than Game A. So if that statement is true and Games C and D are better than Game A, Game B cannot be better than Game C or Game D because it isn’t better than Game A.

What To Do With the List?

After you rank everything, then you can export your list or copy it over to somewhere and share you Top 100 Board Games. How you want to do that is up to you, but let’s look at some ways I’ve seen people share them.

The first one would be to do a video. I do that, The Dice Tower and Man vs Meeple do that as well. But not everyone is going to have the set-up for it. Another option is going to be to create an article. If you create an article you can share it assuming you have a blog. That I kind of do when I share the videos here on the website. There are other spots as well to share it like board game groups on Facebook.

Or, one that I want to start doing each year, is create a Geek List on Board Game Geek of my Top 100 Board Games. That is one that I’d recommend if you don’t have your own website or channel. It is public and it is a spot where board game lovers all come together and enjoy the hobby. So it’s a great spot to share your list.

My Top 100 Board Games

So let’s talk about my schedule. Normally I run into Thanksgiving and that throws off when that last one comes out. Because of that I am starting my list earlier this year. Every Wednesday at 9 PM Central starting September 10th and going through November 12th I will do my next 10 on the list. My hope is to get those video links posted ahead of time so that I can share them about and you can join me.

Which, that leads me to one last spot to share your Top 100. When I do my Top 100 and talk about a number, drop yours in the chat or in the comments. If you are live, drop them as I go along and match up with my number with your game at that number. Or drop in the chat the games of yours that fall into that section of the Top 100 Games (of all time) 2025 Edition.

Send an Email
Message me on X at @TheScando
Visit us on Facebook here
Support us on Patreon here