Now, this list is obviously very subjective. But I wanted to do it to bring to attention some games that I think people are kind of sleeping on. These are going to be board games that I’m a champion for. And maybe it’s other people not liking them, but it’s also games where I think just enough people don’t know about them. And I really want to hit on that aspect of it. I know that some games I love and other people don’t. But what are some that people just don’t know about and they should?

Top 10 Overlooked Games

The criteria for this list is pretty simple. I went through the games that I have rated on Board Game Geek. I sorted them by how I rated them, and then also looked at how many rating total they had. And with that I then created the list. It is not purely the highest rated for me, or the fewest ratings. Because some games I don’t think are super overlooked, they just won’t work for some people instead. And some games are so new the number of ratings is lower so they don’t count as they are going to go higher in terms of total ratings.

10. The Night Cage

There are so many games that I could put on the list, but I want to go with one that is dark and feels different to kick the list off. In The Night Cage players work together to escape this every changing labyrinth before the time runs out and there are no more tiles. But it’s dark, you can only crawl around and there are monsters.

On a turn players move looking for exit points and keys. Each player needs a key and then all the players need to be at the exit at the same time. As you move you illuminate the spots adjacent to you. This might cause a monster to appear. And monsters will blow out your light, or kill you if you have no light. And if your light goes out, well, then you can’t see the spaces around you so you move blind.

Plus, there is a timer in the game, the timer being the number of tiles. So while you want to stay separated to not potentially cause monster problems, if you stay separated, you are more apt to burn through tiles too fast. It’s a great game with a great theme that I think more people should play. It’s really a press your luck game, but if you play it Halloween with some spooky music on, candles, and dimmed lights, it’s great.

9. First Rat

In 2022 this game flew off the shelves at Gen Con. And content creators consistently had it as a high game on their anticipated list. But now, it’s still sitting under 5,000 ratings on Board Game Geek three years later. And I think that more people should play this game because it’s a ton of fun with the theme and with the game play.

In the game you are rats who want to build a spaceship because they believe the moon is made of cheese. First off, how can you not like that theme. Then the game play is really interesting. You collect goods by moving up a track. These goods you use to build your rocket. And you get points for completing parts of them. But there are other elements on the track such as lighting up your way. When you do that, you get more goods.

The game while keeping turns pretty simple offers a lot of fun choices. And while it looks like there is a bunch going on, it isn’t too bad at all. Maybe it’s because they didn’t have enough copies at Gen Con in 2022 that it kind of fell off when people couldn’t buy it. But more people need to checkout First Rat.

8. Medium

This one surprises me that people haven’t rated it more. Yes, I’ll talk about it more but Board Game Geek often times has more ratings for bigger games and non-party games. But Medium is a pretty simple party game was relatively available for a little bit. It even had an expansion. And it is a game that I think more people should try, because it’s silly and fun.

Now maybe the reason it’s less rated is that if you learn the rules you don’t really need the game to play it. The game is very simple in two people go at a time. Each plays out a word and then they come up with a word that connects to two words. If they get it right, they get some points. If not, they try again with the two new words. And if they get that right, it’s fewer points but they get points. And finally you get one more go for the lowest point total, always off of the new words.

I think if more people played it, they would enjoy it as a fun time. And it’s a great icebreaker sort of party game. Because who cares if you get it wrong, it’s always going to lead to conversation around “why did you say that word” or excitement if you get it on the first try.

7. The Reckoners

Why is this game not more rated and more popular? I really like that The Reckoners is a great cooperative game. Plus the theme is fun. Though that is probably some of the reason that it is less popular or rated as well as it being a crowdfunding game mainly.

In this game you play as The Reckoners. A team of humans who are going up against the epics. These are superpowered individuals. But there is a trick, every superpowered individual, when they get their powers, turns bad. So you need to take them down. You complete this in two ways, by damage and by research to find their weakness.

This game is also great because everyone does stuff at the same time. You all roll dice at the same time to set your actions. Then you discuss what you want to do as you roll the dice. And you keep some and reroll, Yahtzee style, to see what other actions you get. Then when you take actions you all do it at the same time as well. It creates a game with almost no downtime, which I know a lot of people like.

6. Paper Dungeons

I don’t want to only put smaller games on the list or roll and write games on the list, but I think that it is pretty common. Why, because a small box game, it’s easier for people to overlook them. Though Paper Dungeons isn’t the smallest box game on the list and it has a pretty epic cover. But it’s probably overlooked because it is a roll and write game.

This game offers a campaign as well, but it’s really a one off game where you are delving into a dungeon and trying to build up your adventuring party through leveling them up, fighting monsters, crafting gear and more. You roll a bunch of dice, and you try and use them the best you can by filling in spots.

But this game is more interactive than some roll and writes. You can all fight the same monsters, but gems are limited to who gets them first. And who does the most damage to a monster, or if you even make it through the dungeon to fight the monster. And that’s a nice added element to it. Plus with Paper Dungeons the complexity is higher than some roll and writes. So that offers more of challenge as you play.

5. Ohanami

Some games are just probably too simple looking to get a ton of ratings. If you play games and rate them on Board Game Geek you probably play a lot of bigger hobby games. Ohanami is one of those small games that I think more people should play because it’s great for playing with people who play fewer games.

The game is pretty simple, you draft cards to add to up to three columns. There is a trick though as you draft the cards, you need to play them to the top or bottom of a column. Now it doesn’t need to be the same column for each card you draft, you draft two at a time, but they need to be higher or lower than the card at the top or bottom of the column.

Along with that, I think the scoring helps make the game more enjoyable for people who play a lot of games. You score different colors of cards different numbers of rounds. You draft over three rounds, but only blue is scored each round. Then green is scored two and grey is scored one. But the points get higher, so it creates a strategic drafting strategy as well as drafting for the numbers.

4. Sonora

This is one that I am very surprised didn’t catch on more. Sonora is a roll and write game, but instead of rolling dice, you are flicking discs. After everyone flicks their discs you use them and the number on the disc from the quadrant where the disc landed.

I kind of understand why some people might not love this game. But it is such a fun time as you play and I love how combotastic the game is. But that is the reason why people might not love the game. It is so combotastic that you might feel overwhelmed as you fill in that part. Or you might not like the randomness of the flicking. But the game, to me, is just a lot of fun. And with how popular roll and write games were, I think this game should have gotten more love.

3. Xenoshyft

This one I’m a champion of, but I think more people should play it. This is a cooperative deck building tower defense game. You play as marines, or something like that, defending a base against bugs. Is this game basically Starship Troopers, yes, and that is great.

The biggest thing I think more people should play this game for three elements that I like a lot. First, it is a very cooperative and collaborative in nature. You help people when they defend their part of the base. And this really leads into the second element of how you do that. You might give them a troop that you bought. They add it to their defensive line. And when it dies, it goes to their deck which is a fun twist. The final one is that you always can buy. This game gives you money and let’s you thin money out of your deck in a way that is great and helpful.

2. For Northwood!

This one is my #2 game that I think more people need to play. Now, I know why the game is on this list. For Northwood is a solo game, and solo games tend to have lower ratings. I skipped over a number of campaign games for that reason to make the list. But Forth Northwood is just so good that I think a lot of people would enjoy it and more people should check it out.

Like I said, For Northwood is a solo trick taking game. You play it over a number of rounds trying to win different numbers of tricks. You go to different forest locations and depending on where it is that sets the number of tricks you need to win, that number exactly, no more or less. Fortunately there are woodland creatures who help you. But that is limited and you need to figure out how to use them best to hit that number.

For Northwood is just such a great puzzle of a game. And each time can be different as you play. If you feel like the base mode of the game is too easy too, it offers you challenges to play. Plus, I think this is a great game for people who want to game but maybe travel a bunch for work as it’s tiny and easy to take with you anywhere.

1. Homebrewers

Homebrewers is easily my #1 game on this list. And it makes me sad that more people haven’t played it and loved this game. Now, I know that I’m also an outlier on rating the game and I’m not sure why. This is a very fun game about brewing beer and seeing who can be the best homebrewer. Now the theme is probably some of why it is less rated, but still, I think it’s a fun theme.

In this game you roll dice for actions and then you can trade dice with your opponents. You do this because you want to brew the best beers so you can score the highest ratings during Summer Fest and Oktoberfest. And you need to do all the steps to brew beer that you’d do in real life, or at least the board game version of them. Plus you add in flavorings to your beers as you brew, and these cards stick around. It allows you to create a brewing engine which is a lot of fun and you can create some crazy beers to drink.

This game, like I said, didn’t do well, and now it’s been six years, so I don’t think it’s going to come back. The upside is because it wasn’t super popular, people don’t sell it for a lot. So if it sounds fun and you can find it, it won’t be too expensive.

Final Thoughts

Now, I know not all games are for all people. But these are some games that I just wish more people would try or could have tried. Because some of them, like Homebrewers, it’s just not going to happen until someone new gets the rights to make the game. Others, I think they have a chance to have more people find them. But I do think that more people would enjoy all of these games.

And I also no the reason that some are passed is just because there are so many. Paper Dungeons and Sonora both came out in the height of roll and write fever. So it is easy to have either been burned out on roll and writes or just skipped them in favor of others that were more popular. But now it might be the chance to try and find them and play them.

What is one game that you’re a champion for that is less than 5,000 ratings on Board Game Geek and has been out for a bit?

Send an Email
Message me on X at @TheScando
Visit us on Facebook here
Support us on Patreon here